Your Kid Won’t Listen. You’ve Tried Everything. Now What?

It’s 7:30. Your three-year-old needs to brush her teeth. You ask her to come into the bathroom. She says no. You tell her she can pick which toothbrush she wants to use. She doesn’t want either one. You offer to brush your teeth together. No. You try making it a game. She runs away.

Now you’re getting annoyed.

You’ve been doing this long enough to know that getting angry isn’t going to help, so you try to stay patient. You explain why brushing teeth is important. You offer one more choice. You remind her that she can’t have a bedtime story until her teeth are brushed.

She’s crying now. You’re getting louder.

Eventually, you either give up or manage to get her teeth brushed while she’s screaming. And you walk out of the bathroom thinking, There has GOT to be a better way to do this. Because seriously. It’s brushing teeth. Why does everything have to be so difficult?

Later that night, you find yourself scrolling through Instagram, watching a parenting expert explain how to get toddlers to cooperate without yelling.

You save the post. Maybe tomorrow you’ll try that.

You’ve become really good at looking for answers.

Think about how much time you spend trying to figure out how to get your kids to do the things they need to do. Getting dressed in the morning. Leaving the playground. Sitting down for dinner. Getting into the car seat. Going to sleep.

You’ve read the books. You’ve listened to the podcasts. You follow the parenting accounts. You know you’re supposed to validate feelings, offer choices, stay calm, and hold boundaries. Sometimes those things work beautifully, but other times your kid couldn’t care less about your carefully worded request. And when something doesn’t work, what do you do? You look for another way.

Maybe you need to be more consistent. Maybe you’re giving too many choices. Maybe you need a better bedtime routine. Maybe you’re not being firm enough. You make adjustments. You try again. And when that doesn’t work either, you start wondering what you’re missing.

I want you to consider something. What if you’re not missing anything?

What if your child sometimes refuses to cooperate because she’s three years old, she has her own ideas about what she wants to do, and brushing her teeth isn’t one of them? What if there isn’t a magical combination of words that will make her happily agree to everything you ask?

And what if you’ve been spending an enormous amount of energy trying to find one?

When did getting your child to cooperate become the goal?

Of course you want your child to listen. You need to get out the door in the morning, and you need her to hold your hand in the parking lot. You need her to brush her teeth. These are reasonable expectations. But somewhere along the way, it’s easy to start believing that if you’re handling things correctly, your child should cooperate.

Like, if you explain things the right way, she’ll understand, and if you offer the right choices, she’ll make one. You tell yourself, if you stay calm enough, she’ll stay calm too. And if none of that works, you must need to do something differently.

I see this all the time with mothers who are thoughtful, capable, and deeply committed to raising their children well. They approach parenting challenges the same way they’ve approached other challenges in their lives. They gather information, consider their options, make a plan, and work toward a solution. It’s an approach that has served them well in so many areas. But there’s something different about raising children.

You can do everything right and your child can still be upset. You can make a reasonable request and your child can refuse. You can set a loving boundary and your child can hate it. You can respond with patience and understanding and still end up with a screaming toddler on the bathroom floor.

And none of those things necessarily means you’ve handled the situation poorly.

Your three-year-old isn’t the only one having a hard time accepting that things aren’t going her way.

Think about it— Your daughter doesn’t want to brush her teeth. She wants to keep playing. You want her to brush her teeth so you can finish bedtime and get on with your evening. She’s frustrated because you’re asking her to do something she doesn’t want to do. You’re frustrated because she’s refusing to do something you want her to do. And the harder you both try to get your way, the more upset everyone becomes.

Now, there’s an important difference here. You’re the adult. You’re responsible for making sure your child’s teeth get brushed, and you have a lot more ability to manage your reactions than your three-year-old does. But that doesn’t mean you’re going to like it when things don’t go your way. And maybe that’s something worth recognizing.

You don’t have to like your child’s behavior to be able to handle it.

You can wish she’d cooperate. You can be annoyed that bedtime is taking longer than you’d hoped. You can want nothing more than to get downstairs and sit on the couch. And you can still be the parent you want to be.

You don’t have to get rid of your frustration any more than you have to get rid of hers. You just have to figure out how to move through the moment together.

Think about what happens when you believe there must be a better way.

Let’s go back to the toothbrushing battle. Your daughter refuses to brush her teeth and so you try one approach. It doesn’t work. You try another. Still no. Now you’re starting to feel frustrated.

You know you shouldn’t yell, but you’re running out of patience. You start thinking about how late it’s getting and how much you still need to do before you can finally sit down. You try one more thing. And… she screams. Now you’re really angry. Suddenly, what started as a simple request has turned into a twenty-minute battle that leaves both of you upset.

Here’s what I want you to notice… You weren’t just trying to get her teeth brushed, you were also trying to find a way to get her teeth brushed without her getting upset. And when she kept getting upset, you kept searching for something that would work. That’s a lot of pressure to put on yourself because while you have some control over how you approach your child, you don’t have control over whether she likes what you’re asking her to do.

And the more you believe you should be able to find a way to make her cooperate, the more frustrating it becomes when you can’t.

It’s easy to get so caught up in trying to make the situation go differently that you lose sight of what’s actually happening. Your child doesn’t want to brush her teeth. You want her to brush her teeth. That’s the situation.

It doesn’t necessarily need a more creative solution. It needs a parent who can help her through it.

You might be making some of these moments harder than they need to be.

I know that’s probably not what you want to hear. You’re already working hard, I know. You’re already trying to be patient. The last thing you need is someone telling you that you’re making things worse. But, I want you to think about how much easier some of these moments might become if you stopped expecting yourself to find a way to make them go smoothly.

Your child doesn’t want to leave the playground, and you can acknowledge that she’s disappointed and still leave. Your child wants another cookie, and you can say no and allow her to be upset about it. Your three-year-old refuses to brush her teeth, and you can be kind, offer some help, and hold the expectation that her teeth need to be brushed.

She might cry. She might protest. She might even tell you that you’re the meanest mommy in the whole world. And you can still be doing exactly what she needs you to do.

This doesn’t mean ignoring your child’s feelings or forcing your way through every disagreement. Sometimes a different approach really is helpful. Sometimes your child needs more support, more time, or a change in expectations.

But, your child’s unhappiness doesn’t automatically mean you need to change what you’re doing. And I wonder how much energy you might get back if you really understood that.

What if you stopped looking for the perfect response?

The next time your kiddo refuses to do something you’ve asked, try noticing what happens next.

Do you immediately start negotiating? Do you explain yourself again, hoping this time she’ll understand? Do you offer another choice, even though you’ve already offered three? Do you feel yourself getting more frustrated with every attempt?

If so, I want you to try something. Before you come up with another strategy, ask yourself: Am I trying to help my child do something she needs to do, or am I trying to find a way to make sure she doesn’t get upset about it? Those are two very different things.

Your kiddo might need your help figuring something out, and sometimes changing your approach is necessary. But sometimes she just needs you to be okay with the fact that she’s not happy. You don’t have to convince her that brushing her teeth is a wonderful idea. You don’t have to find a way to make leaving the playground fun. You don’t have to get her to agree that your decision is fair.

You can listen, you can be understanding, you can hold a boundary. And you can let her have her feelings about it.

Imagine how different your evenings could feel.

Imagine it’s 7:30 tomorrow night. Your daughter refuses to brush her teeth and so you offer her a choice. She says no. Instead of immediately trying to figure out what else you can do, you recognize that she doesn’t want to brush her teeth.

You understand. If you’re being honest, you don’t particularly want to brush yours either. You tell her it’s time, and you offer to help. She gets upset. You don’t love that she’s upset. You’d certainly prefer that she cooperate. But you don’t spend the next twenty minutes trying to figure out how to prevent her from having that reaction. You help her get through it.

Maybe it still takes a while. Maybe there are tears and maybe you have to slow down and try again in a few minutes. But you don’t leave the bathroom feeling like you’ve failed because your daughter wasn’t happy. And you don’t spend the rest of your evening wondering what you should have done differently.

You go downstairs. You sit on the couch. You enjoy a little time to yourself. Because the fact that your three-year-old didn’t want to brush her teeth doesn’t have to become another problem for you to solve.

You don’t need another parenting trick for every difficult moment.

I want to be clear here. I’m not suggesting that parenting strategies are useless. There are amazing tools that can help you understand your child’s development, communicate more effectively, and create routines that work for your family. But no strategy will eliminate your kids frustration, disappointment, or resistance. If you’re waiting to feel like a good mother until you can consistently get your child to cooperate, you’re going to spend a lot of time feeling like you’re falling short. Really short.

Your child is a person. She has her own feelings, preferences, and opinions. Sometimes those will line up beautifully with yours, and sometimes (often?) they won’t. You can have an incredible relationship with your child without agreeing on everything. You can be a loving mother without always knowing exactly what to say. You can handle a situation well even when your child doesn’t like how it turns out.

And you can stop treating every difficult moment as a problem you haven’t figured out how to solve.

Think about what that might mean for your day. Less negotiating. Less second-guessing. Less searching for the perfect words. More time actually being with your child. More patience for the moments that really do require it. And maybe, at the end of the day, a little less wondering whether you’re doing any of this right.

You don’t need your child to be happy with every decision you make to know that you’re taking good care of her. You don’t need every interaction to go well to have a good relationship with your child. Sometimes the most helpful thing you can do is stop trying to make the moment go perfectly and just be there with your kid.

Even when she’s screaming about her toothbrush.

Next
Next

Why You Keep Thinking Motherhood Will Get Easier (And What Actually Helps)